Stack & Tilt Brainwashing | Golf Monthly

There are several issues I have with s&t

1. It assumes too much
2. It prays on the uneducated
3. There is nowhere you can go to learn how to teach s&t so when you are looking for someone to teach it, you don't know what you're going to get.
4. If you teach yourself from the book, do you know what to change first?

Basically, one of the main points is the weight shift is different.
The s&t experts tell us that the vast majority of conventional golfers have a huge sway on the backswing which is clearly wrong.
Tilting your shoulders will happen naturally if you keep in your posture.

For those of you who have swapped and are having success, is it not possible that your ball striking has improved just because you're now simply keeping yourself more centred?

As I understand, s&t was developed over 10 years ago and what I'd like to know is if it's so good, why isn't the tour full of players using it and winning week in week out?

I also object strongly being told I'm teaching a wrong method, a method that doesn't work.
Again, wrong.

And finally, my concern is that the damage it can do to a self taught player. Without supervision, it can lead to problems in the future with possible back problems and reverse pivots.

If you try it and it helps you enjoy your golf, great... but dont tell me it's the only way to swing and all other swings are wrong.

Would I teach s&t ?

No.